Tulna karein
Aam paksha vs Bharat Banao — ek hi page par.
Yeh hum nahi keh rahe ki hum 'achhe' hain aur baki 'bure.' Hum keh rahe hain ki niche jo 12 cheezein hain, woh saari aaj public hain — pramanikta protocol ke saath. Aam paksha mein yeh saari cheezein closed hain. Tulna khud karo.
| Topic | Aam paksha | Bharat Banao |
|---|---|---|
| Candidate selection | ✗High-command list deti hai. Member sirf 'approve' karte hain. | ✓6-step public process: application → dossier → objection window → debate → member secret ballot → Vikas Contract. |
| Manifesto | ✗Election se pehle release. Election ke baad bhul jaata hai. | ✓Manifesto nahi — Vikas Contract. 6 specific commitments. Election se pehle public mein sign. Phir 4 milestones par public hisaab. |
| Hisaab kab dete hain? | ✗5 saal mein ek baar — agle chunaav se pehle. | ✓4 milestones: First 100-Day Action Report, 6-Month Naagrik Review, Annual Vikas Report Card, 5-Year Final Vikas Hisaab. Saath har 90 din mein funding aur progress updates. |
| Funding source | ✗Anonymous + corporate + electoral bonds. Source chhupa. | ✓Sirf individual digital donations. ₹50,000/saal cap. Corporate / foreign / anonymous kabhi nahi. Cash kabhi nahi. |
| Funding ka hisaab | ✗ECI ko yearly file karte hain — janta ko nahi. | ✓Public ledger har 90 din mein PDF. Anonymized donor list live /funding par. Independent CA yearly rotate. |
| Member ka role | ✗Follower. Slogans repeat karna, rally mein aana, vote dena. Decision mein zero awaaz. | ✓Decision-maker. Candidate vote, ward priorities, Naagrik Sabha questions, party-wide policy vote, ethics committee election. Vote weight = 1 for every member, including Member #1. |
| Defection (party badlna) | ✗Welcome — naya pratyashi mil gaya. | ✓Mid-term defection: Vikas Contract auto-void, public refund of paksha-kharch ka share, expulsion process. Naam expulsion log par 2 saal ke liye. |
| Member data | ✗Phone, address, voter ID, jaati, dharm — sab collect. Aksar third-parties ko bechte hain. | ✓Sirf naam, phone, ward. Aadhaar / jaati / dharm — kabhi nahi. Politicians ke saath share — kabhi nahi. Code-level lock. |
| Naagrik Sabha (local meeting) | ✗Ho hi nahi pati. Kabhi-kabhi photo-op ke liye. | ✓Default har mahine. Chunaav mein har 15 din. Minutes 48 ghante mein public. Attendance + photos + decisions sab record. |
| Internal voting | ✗Closed-room. 'Consensus' nakli. Aksar pre-decided. | ✓Secret ballot. Result + breakdown + abstain count public. Code open-source. |
| Code aur data | ✗Closed. Vendor proprietary. Audit-able nahi. | ✓Open source on GitHub. Signed commits. Database schema public. Bug bounty live. |
| Constitution (samvidhan) | ✗Hai, par padhna mushkil. Badalna president ya parliamentary board kar deta hai. | ✓v0.1 draft public on /samvidhaan. v1.0 member feedback ke baad. Amendment ke liye two-thirds member vote chahiye. Office bearer ek tarafa nahi badal sakte. |
Candidate selection
✗High-command list deti hai. Member sirf 'approve' karte hain.
✓6-step public process: application → dossier → objection window → debate → member secret ballot → Vikas Contract.
Manifesto
✗Election se pehle release. Election ke baad bhul jaata hai.
✓Manifesto nahi — Vikas Contract. 6 specific commitments. Election se pehle public mein sign. Phir 4 milestones par public hisaab.
Hisaab kab dete hain?
✗5 saal mein ek baar — agle chunaav se pehle.
✓4 milestones: First 100-Day Action Report, 6-Month Naagrik Review, Annual Vikas Report Card, 5-Year Final Vikas Hisaab. Saath har 90 din mein funding aur progress updates.
Funding source
✗Anonymous + corporate + electoral bonds. Source chhupa.
✓Sirf individual digital donations. ₹50,000/saal cap. Corporate / foreign / anonymous kabhi nahi. Cash kabhi nahi.
Funding ka hisaab
✗ECI ko yearly file karte hain — janta ko nahi.
✓Public ledger har 90 din mein PDF. Anonymized donor list live /funding par. Independent CA yearly rotate.
Member ka role
✗Follower. Slogans repeat karna, rally mein aana, vote dena. Decision mein zero awaaz.
✓Decision-maker. Candidate vote, ward priorities, Naagrik Sabha questions, party-wide policy vote, ethics committee election. Vote weight = 1 for every member, including Member #1.
Defection (party badlna)
✗Welcome — naya pratyashi mil gaya.
✓Mid-term defection: Vikas Contract auto-void, public refund of paksha-kharch ka share, expulsion process. Naam expulsion log par 2 saal ke liye.
Member data
✗Phone, address, voter ID, jaati, dharm — sab collect. Aksar third-parties ko bechte hain.
✓Sirf naam, phone, ward. Aadhaar / jaati / dharm — kabhi nahi. Politicians ke saath share — kabhi nahi. Code-level lock.
Naagrik Sabha (local meeting)
✗Ho hi nahi pati. Kabhi-kabhi photo-op ke liye.
✓Default har mahine. Chunaav mein har 15 din. Minutes 48 ghante mein public. Attendance + photos + decisions sab record.
Internal voting
✗Closed-room. 'Consensus' nakli. Aksar pre-decided.
✓Secret ballot. Result + breakdown + abstain count public. Code open-source.
Code aur data
✗Closed. Vendor proprietary. Audit-able nahi.
✓Open source on GitHub. Signed commits. Database schema public. Bug bounty live.
Constitution (samvidhan)
✗Hai, par padhna mushkil. Badalna president ya parliamentary board kar deta hai.
✓v0.1 draft public on /samvidhaan. v1.0 member feedback ke baad. Amendment ke liye two-thirds member vote chahiye. Office bearer ek tarafa nahi badal sakte.
Yeh tulna khud verify karo
Aam paksha ke baare mein har dawa public records se aaya — chunaav affidavits, ECI filings, court cases, RTI replies. Hamare baare mein har dawa /pramanikta + /samvidhaan + /transparency-log + /funding par live aur public hai. Galat dikha to grievance file karo.
Saaf baat: 'Aam paksha' kisi ek party ka naam nahi — yeh woh aam pattern hai jo zyaadatar parties mein dikhta hai. Hum kisi party ya neta ka naam nahi lete.